Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Carolita Johnson's avatar

I’m half wondering if this entire eloquent and vulnerable response wasn’t just the usual reflexive emotional work by a woman in response to a man in distress, and I’m gonna have to think about that first. Meanwhile, it was a good response to a letter that began well, had a good twist, drew me in, and then lost me at the part where women get him wrong because he’s too good to be true. The last time I said something similar about myself I was twenty years younger and being enabled by people who actually let me believe it. None of us are that good. And I definitely feel wary around anyone who allows themselves to say such things about themselves, including me. I have set my own alarm bells off many a time!

But maybe this letter was a good effort, a good start. PS- Please don’t become enraged. PPS- it’s telling that I wanted to say something but was frankly afraid to, and am now using dark humor to frame that.

Expand full comment
mia's avatar

Amazing letter + response. As a woman probably around LW's age, I will say that I've become resistant of men who openly tout their emotional intelligence and other wonderful sensitivities. It used to be the opposite, but after falling for a guy who was always mentioning how important integrity was to him, and then later finding out he was cheating on his girlfriend with me, I started to pay more attention. The kindest, most honest and emotional men were never the ones always talking about their kindness, honesty, and emotion. They just were. Or, if pressed, they'd say, "I try my best but I'm sure I could be better." So when I read that women are dismissive of LW because they don't believe he's real - my first thought was - there's something about his behavior that's coming across as disingenuous or not real, and it's not just how great he is ;) And if that's not true, he may be choosing women who genuinely prefer to date jerks (I have some friends who will openly admit to this). So *then* the question is - why?

Expand full comment
74 more comments...

No posts