Untitled (1940), Yves Tanguy
Dear Polly,
Is this thing on? Because it’s all starting to feel a little unreal. A little dystopian. I just turned 21 last week, and I know that’s not exactly old, but I’m not sure I can handle much more of this.
What am I referring to, exactly? What’s so “dystopian”? All of it, friend. The whole damn thing. I’m losing my mind out here, Polly. There’s not a single thing going on right now I feel normal about.
I am someone — like you, probably, and like most of your readers — who feels deeply, cares a lot, and can’t turn her emotions off. I just want to do right by the world, Polly, and so I’ve built my aimless college-dropout life around that. For lack of a better explanation, I have nothing going on; I have no friends, I have no hobbies, I hate my job, I rarely leave my apartment. And so I have crafted a careful individual lifestyle based around the one thing I can control, which is myself, and I have taken it upon myself to do the most I can to help the world individually, which is things like going to my local refillery, buying at the bulk bins, not using single-use items, wearing cotton instead of polyester, reducing my food waste, taking the bus, and so on. I am a firm believer in the idea that one individual DOES make a difference, especially when it comes to practicing an increasingly-necessary eco-friendly lifestyle. But Polly, it is not enough.
I am learning more and more about the horrors of this world and the world is only growing worse around me. I recently watched a documentary called Dominion, which was basically 2 hours of horrifying, shocking footage of the daily plight of farmed animals in factory farms. It was so awful, Polly. It made me ashamed to be a human, and I am feeling this more and more every day. I’ve since gone vegan and am excited to make a difference in my own way—being vegan is, I learned, also the number one way to reduce your climate impact, since animal agriculture is one of the largest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions—but it is not enough. Everywhere I turn, it’s horrifying. Not only are humans brutally killing animals in factory farms, we are killing our planet, we are killing nature, we are killing the beautiful biodiversity of species. We are destroying this planet at rates never before seen. Animals, insects, endangered species, unique and wonderful kinds of plant life, all disappearing forever because of our carelessness and greed. The plastic pollution crisis is at an all-time extreme. The average person in the US is producing more than four pounds of waste every single day, much of which will take hundreds of years to decompose, and even then plastic waste only breaks down into pernicious microplastics. And all this while humans, too, suffer, starve, and die every day. All this while humans kill each other and hurt each other for no reason. All this while women are oppressed in Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, so many places. All this while intelligent creatures languish in pet stores, in captivity, in factory farms by the billions. (I could go on.) All this while no one I talk to about any of these things—and I am a kind person, Polly, I am not brash or harsh or difficult to speak to—cares one bit, or makes any kinds of changes at all.
I can’t stand it anymore, Polly. I’m hearing that we’re at the point where climate change could truly become irreversible; I’m hearing that AI has a 10% chance of killing us all in the next ten years; I’m witnessing every day the effects of social media and technology on people’s ability to relate to, interact with, and even start a freaking conversation with each other, which is, as you can imagine, vast. (I don’t even have a smartphone. I have a flip phone because I hate tech and social media so much. I wasn’t alive in the time when people spoke to each other in the elevator or interacted on the bus or in the grocery store line; tell me, was it as pleasant as it sounds?) As far as the AI thing goes—god, I don’t even want to talk about it because I can’t stand hearing or reading or thinking about it anymore, I hate it so much, the ads, the images, the videos—the IMPLICATIONS of using AI for everything and all these huge companies starting to use it—to sum it all up, Polly, it’s starting to feel a little unreal. Climate change, robots, school shootings, social media, factory farming, our fucking (can I say that?) president. I can’t wrap my head around the fact that this is the time and the world I’m living in: a doomsday. The beginning of the end of it all.
Even though I am a college dropout working at an Asian restaurant and doing nothing important with my life, I do my part. I live by my values. I send emails to companies every day, I stand up for humans and animals alike, I donate blood every two months (and money I don’t have), I educate others where I can. I am always searching for ways to do better. When I was a senior in high school, I crafted a letter and a presentation and I dressed in a suit and brought a briefcase full of infographs and samples to the school board, imploring them to stop using Styrofoam trays for lunch in our county and instead consider washable or at least biodegradable trays and utensils. And it worked. Every single school in my county switched from Styrofoam lunch trays and plastic single-use utensils to compostable trays and utensils. And I did that, Polly, all by myself, alone. I made that change. But that’s just it—I did it alone. I got quotes from other students that I used in my presentation, but no one except a scattered few teachers cared enough to work alongside me or help me achieve this goal. And that’s what my life feels like. I care SO MUCH, and no one else does. Why?
I don’t want to be a downer. I promise, I’m a nice person, I’m funny, I’m kind, if you met me in person you’d probably think I was charming in my own right. But the other factor in this whole thing, Polly, is that I’m only 21, and I’ve somehow lived through four separate suicide attempts, the first when I was only 12. I didn’t have a youth I like to look back on. I never had true friends. I’ve always had ambitions but never motivation. I wanted to be a singer, I still do, more than anything — I know I have the talent, but I just don’t know how I’d do it. I wanted to be in theater and be a dancer, or be a writer; I love to write, too. Or I just wanted to help people. My whole life, I’ve always just wanted to help people, to help animals, to make the world a better place. But I don’t have anyone to lean on. No one really gets me. I didn’t have a role model or a lot of help to do anything. And so I’m simply stuck, with no path in life, nobody who supports me in my goals of trying to improve the world, no clue how to even get on my feet. I often think that I could rally the world if I just had the opportunity, had an audience to listen—that if I were brave and motivated enough to get through college, somehow get a nonprofit job or a job doing something I love, I could make a real difference. A difference that would help me, and help the world, help the animals, help the less fortunate. But I am simply stuck.
I never really liked my life, or being alive in this world. And the more I learn, the harder I try and the less I see everyone else trying, the more difficult it is for me to take it. I’m not suicidal or even really depressed, I promise; I just need a little direction. What do I do, Polly? My eyes opened to the horrors of the world when I was young, and they haven’t shut since. When everyone else is ignorant or blind, how can I possibly find a home or a purpose in this place?
It’s Starting To Feel Dystopian
Dear ISTFD,
I know how you feel. I know what you mean. I know, I know, I know.
But it would be easier not to run your letter. It kicks up so much pain, reading your words. It would be easier to ignore what you wrote, forget about it completely if possible, and then write something bright and cheerful about optimism and joy — Hey, you know what helps? Walking through the woods! Reading a great book! Playing with an adorable puppy! — while blocking out everything terrifying and corrupt and deeply sad in the world.
It would be easier to turn away, to refuse to acknowledge the despair under my skin that matches your despair perfectly. It would be easier to call you too young, too depressed, too alienated, too different from me, too longwinded, too fixated, too obsessive. Think of all the ways I could write you off! And think of all the ways that everyone who cares too much gets written off, every single day, by so many of people they know — even when their words are a cry for help! Hell, even when their words are NOT a cry for help, even when they’re only making a statement of fact that anyone with a functioning frontal lobe could recognize as true, they still get written off.
Think of how often someone saying something true and real is rejected for it. In a world that feeds us soul-crushing distractions and addictions for profit, truth tellers are encountered as lunatics.
Think of how many times each hour someone on the planet says, “I really hate this” or “This isn’t right” or “We can’t live this way” and someone else says “Yeah, whatever, we all know that,” in a tone that implies that you should never say anything that someone else has already said, no matter how true it is, as if a human’s entire purpose is to create new, sparkly content for other humans to ingest, and if the content isn’t shiny and upbeat, or titillating, or witty, or concise, that human should be ignored.
Think of how lonely the world is becoming by the second, thanks to the fact — the obvious, terrifying fact – that people who express this anxiety and fear and sadness out loud are so often labeled as troublemakers, or shrugged off as mentally ill, even though they’re seeing the whole world through clear eyes and they’re doing something — expressing themselves! — that humans have always done in order to feel more connected, more real, more appreciated, more USEFUL, more alive.
And think about the fact that the people who refuse to acknowledge these facts or feel what’s real, the people who talk in upbeat cliches in order to sell useless, planet-destroying bullshit to other people who don’t want to acknowledge or feel what’s real, are the ones who are labeled HEALTHY and PRODUCTIVE.
But the truth is that it’s incredibly difficult at this moment in human history to acknowledge the truth or make a real connection in real time with someone else who’s willing to acknowledge the truth. Because if you want to feel LESS TERRIBLE instead of feeling overwhelmed by the world of pain and anguish that lives on your phone every second of every day, then you will quite naturally be on the hunt for TASTY DISTRACTIONS and CHEERFUL SOUNDS and SEXY VIBES and ADDICTIVE PUZZLES. You will quite naturally crave much less truth and much less pain and much more ESCAPE.
The ones who care too much are treated like shit. Let’s acknowledge that, to ourselves and each other. Let’s acknowledge that we treat OURSELVES like shit whenever we care too much.
So this is what I want to say to you and everyone else reading these words: We have to support and embrace and LOVE the truth tellers. When someone expresses the awful truth, even when it makes us feel terrible, sad, sick, worried, avoidant, addictive, depressed, panicked, we have to SHOW THE FUCK UP FOR IT.
We all have a responsibility not to turn away from people who are telling the truth about the world. They might be longwinded, bitch! So fucking what? They might be a little wound up! Doesn’t that make simple fucking sense at a time like this?
We have to show up for the people who are in pain. And we have to be gentle with them. We’ll find it easier to do this when we show up for our own pain. We’ll feel capable of offering support when we resolve not to ignore our own sensations — our fears, our sadness, our panic. And when we feel too overwhelmed to help someone, we can recognize that, too, and we can say, “I want to help you, but I can’t at this moment. I’m going to try to get to a place where I can help you soon, if possible.”
The less we guilt ourselves for saying no, the more capable of a YES we become.
Human connection isn’t just a good way to feel a little better on a bad day. It’s not just the only path to saving the world. It’s the center of everything. It’s why we’re here.
We need more of it. So we have to remind ourselves, every single day: We can speak in plain fucking language to each other, in real time. We can pick up the phone and call each other. We can tell the truth to each other: that we tried very hard to care less for a long time, and maybe that was what we needed, but right now, we’re going to show up more, do more, care more again — without trying to control it, without always being the one who’s right, without always demanding that our feelings be acknowledged first and last.
Caring and connecting with real people in real time ALWAYS feels scary. It’s always a risk. It’s not even natural for so many people these days! We hide from it! We optimize it out of our lives!
The more it leaves our lives, the sadder we become.
The less connecting and caring we do, the less we feel.
The more we turn away from the people who are too young, too depressed, too fixated, too sad, too longwinded, too intense, and too much, the more we turn away from OURSELVES.
Remember when you were too much? Yeah, you. Remember? You felt scared. You felt lonely. You needed someone to tell you that it would be okay, even when everything looked completely fucked. You needed someone to stand up and say, LISTEN TO ME. AS LONG AS YOU’RE STILL ALIVE, YOU HAVE TO JUMP THE FUCK IN AND LIVE.
So ISTFD, I know that your life feels impossible. I’ve felt so many of the things you’re feeling right now (including just this morning!) and I recognize that we’re living through a specific kind of terror at this moment that might’ve been nearly impossible for me to face or process when I was your age. And the truth is, my words can only go so far. I can only support you so much from here. What’s sort of sad for me is that I used to believe that I was absolutely special, so special that I could pull you out of the darkness with my words alone. I don’t really believe that anymore.
But I do believe in something much more powerful and magnificent than that now, in a much more consistent, habitual way than I believed in it before. I believe in the uncanny power of just going out the door and looking for other people who care more than they can stand. I believe that connection with those people can drag you out of these feelings of dread and hopelessness.
You have to put yourself in shared spaces with people you don’t know, and you have to observe them patiently, and you have to endure the uncertainty, vulnerability, fear, and rejection of that. It’s not easy. People will disappoint you a lot. But you will gain so much from simply learning to tolerate proximity, and anxiety, and need, and rejection.
But what good will that do? You’re wondering.
It will do more good than you can imagine in this moment. Trusting that, having faith in connection, is hard. If you don’t have any experience with it, it’s even harder.
But I want you to trust it anyway. I also want you to trust your faith in your love of music and performing. I want you to follow that faith, even when you don’t understand it. I want you to cultivate that belief in theater and dancing and music and writing and love the person who believes in it, with all of your heart. I know it’s hard, but trust me, you can do that every day, without any reinforcement from the world outside. I do it every day, and it hurts and takes hard work, even now. You turn ambition into motivation by loving your core passions and committing to the passion itself, knowing that passion is the best part. Motivation is the practice of loving what you love with all of your heart, however you can, every day, regardless of outcomes. Keep the faith. And when you start to show up for that faith, even when you don’t know the practical path forward, you feed your passion and yourself.
Believe in your creative passions, even when there’s no fucking reason under the sun to do so. It matters. Take that on faith. Show up. Feed it. It’s not about results. It’s about spending time with that faith, stoking it, giving it your energy and your love.
Give yourself that gift, every day. Enjoy it now. Don’t make your enjoyment conditional, based on what you manage to achieve. Learn to relish whatever you have, right now, today. Passion is working with nothing and feeling everything anyway. Belief is daring to care in spite of the fact that you’re too young, too old, too untalented, too afraid, too uncertain, too intense, too overwhelmed.
Belief is what heals us in this moment. Belief and connection.
When we dare to believe in each other, in spite of the many, many things that make us hard to love and hard to believe in, we build our strength and we touch joy without even trying to. When we dare to believe in ourselves, in spite of all of our questions and doubts and worries and our impulse to call ourselves fucked and lost and broken and too much, we build love inside our bodies, love that can and will pull someone else out of the darkness, almost by accident.
This world needs your caring and your faith, ISTFD. It needs your energy and your love. I want you to dare to believe that, and I’ll take the leap again and dare to believe it, too.
It’s so easy to doubt everything. Believing is the hardest fucking thing to do.
Do it anyway.
Where do you start? You start by going out into the world and recognizing someone who’s talking too much, asking hard questions, saying out loud, “I don’t want to feel this much, I don’t want to care this much, I don’t know what to do.” And then you say to that person, “I know, I get it, I feel the same way. I’m here. Let’s talk about it for a while.”
Don’t be afraid of looking for these people. Don’t withdraw from them. They matter.
To everyone reading this: We need each other. Let someone intense get a little longwinded today. Don’t judge that. Stop acting like people who care are fucking crazy. The ones with the most incredibly punishing ideals are the ones you need to encourage, support, give your energy to, believe in, create pathways to the sun for. You can still say no when you’re past capacity. But when you have it in you, when you feel it, when you believe, when you understand how much they have to offer, when you see how much YOU have to offer, how much love you’ve cultivated inside yourself, how much you want to help? Give yourself freely. Give your love, your support, your listening ear, your silence, your presence, your electricity, your optimism, your dread, your everything.
Put down your phone. Leave the house. Tell someone to keep going. Tell them you care. Tell them you get it.
And then do it again.
Right now, in the comments, give your love and support to ISTFD. Demonstrate how much of a difference human connection can make.
ISTFD, thank you for writing this letter. I’m coming out of a long sleep, personally, and everything hurts right now. I didn’t want to reply to you. I wanted to forget your words. Taking the leap, feeling this pain, acknowledging the truth, remembering how hard it can be to show yourself in this increasingly cold world: It’s scary, but it feels important. You’ve reminded me that I can’t just take the risk of caring about my own struggles. I also have to loudly, vocally stand up for caring itself, for saying too much, for being too intense. We all do.
We can’t let careless, numb ghouls reduce our world to some gamified high capitalist nightmare. We have to stand up for what’s real. Sometimes we even have to care so much that it’s anxiety-inducing and painful.
We’re strong enough to tolerate that.
Connection with real humans includes pain. We have to dare to love anyway. Acknowledging the state of our world includes pain. We have to dare to live in reality no matter what.
I know things are pretty fucked but life will improve for you, ISTFD. But you have to take risks. You have to try things a new way now. You have to show your heart in spite of the pain.
Think of the risks it took to get you here. You’re a survivor. You’re an artist and a thinker and an idealist. Learn to relish what you are, in spite of everything. Look for people just like you. It will feel scary. You won’t want to care about them. Notice when you feel safe in spite of this. A miracle. My despair matches your despair perfectly. My joy matches your joy. I see you. We create safety together. We create possibility and hope.
Follow the miracles. Follow the hope.
Now you’re living.
Polly
Every day it takes work to keep believing. I’m with you. Thanks for being here. Send your letters to askpolly@protonmail.com.


LW - doubling down on Polly's excellent advice. Leaving your house and finding ways to engage in the real world will save you.
I've had a rough couple years mentally, often living as you did, feeling similar ways. What has pulled me out was doing as much as I could to be in the world and do things. I joined a non-profit arts board with a lot of responsibilities, I talked to people who also struggled, I talked to old friends, I called my mom everyday, I took art classes, I joined a bike team, I made art, I took a 12-week meditation stress relief course (MBSR, they're offered all over the country at low cost, it's basically meditation based group therapy), I volunteered, I started working at a bakery part-time, I joined a co-working space, I held parties, I dated (love is healing even if painful!), I eventually fell in love. These things were hard, these things were great.
I also spent time burrowing inwards, binging dumb shows, reading far too many Ask Polly letters, scrolling on my phone, getting in a daze. I love the internet, I love Polly (to be clear! Polly, you're great, please don't stop), I love reading, I love great films, but you can't think your way out of this, you have to act.
I'm also not a doctor, but I got on a small dose of Wellbutrin earlier this year, and it stabilized me to the point where I was able to make the other choices I needed. It might be the help you need.
Regarding AI...it will not kill us in a Terminator way. It'll kill us slowly. It robs us of our ability to write our own bad poetry. It robs us of following our own curiosity. It destroys our sense of self by telling us what we want to hear. It will atrophy our muscles of comprehension and deep thinking that we've spent thousands of anguished hours building. It reduces everyone's humanity to an organic optimization engine. That's how AI will kill us all.
At least we have a choice. You don't have to use it.
I'm a vegan. I don't have social media. I don't use AI. I'm tedious at parties. I write bad poetry. All my cameras use film and half the exposures don't work out. I talk to everybody and one out of twenty become a friend. I steal back my wages by reading on company time.
I agree with Cory Doctorow's position, that my personal shopping preferences/tastes/habits have no impact on the world in the aggregate, and that we need political change. I do it anyway. It makes me feel more human. And if you don't feel human, if you don't feel pain, then what's the point?